Thomas and Dabney, best friends, Part 2
Earlier, we talked about the deep, lifelong friendship between Thomas Jefferson and Dabney Carr. Their story had big political ideas, a serious teenage promise under a Monticello oak tree, and a heartbreaking goodbye. Yet when we only picture them as serious Virginia lawmakers, we forget they were once just two fun-loving young guys in a slower, simpler world. Long before colonial tensions turned into war and the heavy weight of a revolution fell on Jefferson's shoulders, these two loved to laugh, pull pranks, and just enjoy life.
Their best prank happened around 1760 while they were classmates at Reverend James Maury's boarding school. Carr had a super fast horse, while young Jefferson rode a famously slow pony. Knowing he had the easy win, Carr challenged Jefferson to a race. Jefferson knew his sluggish pony didn't stand a chance, so he agreed on one strict rule: he got to pick the date. Once Carr said yes, Jefferson set the big race for the 30th of February. Since that date doesn't exist on the calendar, Carr could never collect. The Maury family loved that comeback so much they kept telling the story for decades.
Between school breaks, Carr often visited Jefferson at his family home at Shadwell. They spent lazy afternoons riding horses up what they called Tom's mountain, the wooded hill that would later become Monticello. Those hangouts under their favorite oak tree weren't about big historical destiny. They were just two best friends escaping the world with a stack of books and easy talk.
That same lively energy followed them to Williamsburg at the College of William and Mary. During his first year in town, Jefferson jumped right into college life. He blew way too much money on nice horses, danced all night in the Apollo Room at the Raleigh Tavern, and placed small bets on card games, backgammon, and horse races. True to his detail-loving brain, he wrote down every gambling win and loss to the penny in his personal notebook. He also joined a secret campus club called the F.H.C. Club, or the Flat Hat Club, which met at that same tavern for drinks and lively debates.
Years later, Jefferson joked that the six-member club had no real point at all. Since the two friends were so close during their Williamsburg days, it's easy to picture Carr joining right in on the fun, even if old records only show Jefferson's side of things. Feeling guilty about how much time he wasted partying and dancing, Jefferson flipped his routine in year two and forced himself to study 15 hours a day. Even with that tough schedule, Williamsburg still left plenty of room for music, laughs, and good times.
After college, their lives took a quick turn into real frontier toughness before settling into the courtroom. In 1763, Carr put his law studies on hold to fight in the French and Indian War with the Louisa County Volunteer Rangers under Captain Phillips, earning a land reward for his service. Soon after, he started practicing law in Louisa County and quickly got sharp enough that even Patrick Henry saw him as a top rival. Outside of court, though, Carr was totally down-to-earth. After marrying Jefferson's younger sister Martha in July 1765, he moved into a tiny, simple house in Goochland County with very little money or fancy stuff. Visiting them there, Jefferson was amazed by his friend's joy, writing that in a tiny house with just a table, half a dozen chairs, and one or two servants, Dabney was the happiest man in the universe.
By early 1773, their easy teamwork carried straight into politics. In March, they met quietly with Patrick Henry and the Lee brothers at the Raleigh Tavern, the exact same tavern from Jefferson's wild college nights, to write a plan uniting the colonies by setting up a communication network so they wouldn't have to stand alone. After Carr gave his famous speech in the House of Burgesses on the 12th of March, he and Jefferson rode home together, buzzing with excitement over how their plan would spark a meeting of all the colonies.
When a fever took Carr just two months later, it left an empty space Jefferson never filled. Decades later, in an 1816 letter to Carr's younger son, Dabney, Jefferson grieved losing a strong partner right as the colonies were coming together. He admitted that the memory of his old friend, much like losing Dabney's older brother Peter at age 45 just a year earlier in 1815, never came back without a deep sigh, remembering Carr's kindness, warmth, and easygoing company most of all.
History books tend to freeze great men like statues, leaving behind only speeches, laws, and monuments. Yet the laughs behind a fake February horse race and a joyful life in a tiny Virginia house tells a much better truth. Before Jefferson became a Founding Father and Carr died way too young, they were two best friends who knew how to enjoy the ride.