Understanding Jefferson and this Page

The purpose of this post is to answer common questions I see in the many comments on this page and to spell out my overall mindset. At ThomasJefferson.com, the philosophy is built on five core principles. Primary source evidence (such as his letters) is valued over modern assumptions, the rule of innocent until proven guilty is strictly upheld, historical figures are not judged by modern standards, respectful and informed debate is welcomed while drive-by insults are blocked, and Thomas Jefferson is treated with basic human empathy for the massive personal sacrifices he made for this country.

Before diving deeper into those points, let me first set the scene. When it comes to Thomas Jefferson, there are three major types of people. First, there are his admirers. Second, there are his haters. Third, there are the people in the middle who love his accomplishments, just not the other parts of his life.

First of all, this page is for Thomas Jefferson admirers. This is not a blind love for him, but rather a well-researched admiration built on many years of study and reflection. Serious students of history dismiss uninformed attacks because arguments built on myths rather than primary sources are simply not worth debating. Conversely, if you happen to be an admirer who has not done all the research yet, maybe because you simply trusted the opinion of someone you respect, you still ended up on the right side of history. As the old saying goes, it is better to be lucky than good.

Because of this, haters have a short leash here. They are welcome if they come in genuinely wanting to understand. However, if they come into the comments repeating the same tired misinformation without any backup or proof, and refuse to consider and read the materials offered here, they will be blocked. Those old complaints are easily resolved by reading original source documents, which the critics rarely do. That is why they all sound the same, simply parroting talking points from an author or academic with an agenda, accepting everything blindly without any skepticism, critical thinking, or effort to verify if it is actually true. There are better things to do than to entertain amateur, surface-level attacks.

For example, recently a gentleman here was told that Jefferson actually wrote letters denying the Hemings charges, and he replied that he had been reading about Jefferson for over 40 years and had never heard that. Do not assume you know Thomas Jefferson just because you have read poor (usually modern liberal) biographies or have never dug deeper, settling instead for the historical equivalent of junk food. But more often than not, critics are simply everyday readers who were misled by biased academics pushing an agenda to fuel resentment toward Jefferson. If you have seen this irrational hostility firsthand in the academic world, you know exactly what I mean.

On the other hand, if you are a critic who takes the time to read the articles on this page and wants to question specific points or debate the issue respectfully, you are welcome to stay. The fact is, the more you learn the real history surrounding Jefferson, the more you realize he was a good and great man. Serious students of Jefferson and thus admirers determined this to be true a long time ago. There is a reason why some of America's greatest presidents, including Lincoln, FDR, and JFK, deeply admired Thomas Jefferson, and it is because they understood the facts.

Now we come to the people in the middle. They do not particularly love Jefferson, nor do they hate him. They usually understand that we should not judge historical figures by modern standards, yet they struggle to understand why a great man would own slaves, especially when he openly wrote that slavery was wrong.

For this concern, I suggest you start with this post:  https://www.thomasjefferson.com/jefferson-blog/why-thomas-jefferson-did-not-free-his-slaves-did . I have received countless messages thanking me for this piece because it bridges that disconnect. It explains in logical detail, based on real historical facts and Virginia law, why Thomas Jefferson remained a slaveholder. Hint: it was not because he wanted to be.

Another common question from people in the middle is about the rumors of Jefferson having a relationship with an enslaved woman. They often ask what would be so wrong with that. Honestly, if a relationship were based on mutual love, there would be nothing wrong with it, and today it would even be celebrated. The issue here is simply about truth and evidence.

Jefferson himself denied the rumor, and many people close to him backed up his word. Why should anyone accept an accusation that he denied when there is no solid proof? A basic principle of fairness is innocent until proven guilty.

Even today, there is no conclusive proof from DNA to confirm those claims. In fact, DNA even exonerated Jefferson in a major historical rumor, a detail rarely publicized or shared by progressive academics. For over two centuries, many people suspected that a man named Thomas Woodson was Jefferson's son conceived during his time in France, largely because the timeline fit the boy's age perfectly and they shared a first name. The circumstantial evidence was extremely convincing. Yet the 1998 DNA study definitively proved that Jefferson was not his father. Jefferson was telling the truth all along.

Finally, people in the middle often say that Jefferson was just a man who did great things, but also had flaws. That is true of every human being who has ever lived. Saying it is like pointing out that the sun is bright. It is so obvious that it does not need to be said. Nobody feels the need to remind everyone that Thomas Edison was a flawed and hypocritical man, even though he was, just like anyone else. It is completely unnecessary, and it is just as ridiculous to constantly repeat it about Jefferson.

People do this because Jefferson is larger than life, and cynics always want to knock great figures down a peg to feel balanced. They say he was extraordinary, yet in the same breath insist he was complex, a paradox, or a hypocrite. No, Jefferson was a benevolent genius who gave and gave without asking for anything in return. People label him incorrectly simply because they do not understand him. How can you balance out an extraordinary individual by reducing them to ordinary? That goes against the very definition of extraordinary.

When people make flippant, careless remarks about Jefferson, it is wrong. Even though he passed away 200 years ago, people should still show basic human empathy. In his farewell letter to James Madison, Jefferson famously asked his friend to "take care of me when dead." That proves he cared deeply about how future generations would remember him. Given how much he sacrificed for this country, including his family fortune, his personal peace, and his own life, Jefferson deserves to be honored and respected by all Americans.

Thank you, Mr. Jefferson, for all you have done for us. Now it is our responsibility to continue your work and principles.

Thomas Jefferson